Home › Guides › A million NEETs: what the review means for expert evidence on young people's capacity for work
A review by Alan Milburn, published on 17 November 2026, has put young people out of work and education at the centre of public debate. It describes around one million people aged 16 to 24 who are not in education, employment or training, a group usually called NEET. It calls for a “complete system reset” to bring 440,000 young people into work, and it proposes reform across education, employment and social support. For those who write or commission medico-legal reports, the review is a reminder of how often questions about a young person’s capacity for work now arise, and how carefully such questions need to be answered. This guide sets out what the review says, why it is not evidence about any individual, and how an expert can keep the wording of a report within what the evidence shows. It is general information, not legal advice.
What the review says
The review’s central message is that the answer to youth non-employment is a complete system reset, rather than a single fix. It covers education, employment support and the help available to young people who are struggling. It also points to the government’s view that about a third of pupils who are persistently absent in Years 10 and 11 in England go on to become NEET.
These are population figures. They describe large groups and the direction of policy. They do not describe a particular young person, and they do not establish why any individual is out of work. Read the full review before drawing conclusions from it, and be wary of summaries that present a headline figure as if it applied to a single case.
Why population figures are not individual evidence
It is tempting to treat a national statistic as if it answered a question about one person. A report that says a young man is “one of a million” young people out of work, or that a particular teenager is at risk because a third of persistently absent pupils become NEET, is making a leap that the evidence does not support.
A population figure can tell an expert that something is common. It cannot tell the expert whether a given young person can work, how much, in what kind of job, or for how long. Those questions depend on the individual’s history, symptoms, functioning, treatment and prospects. A good report keeps the statistic as background, and the individual’s evidence as the foundation of any opinion.
What the expert is actually asked
Instructions on capacity for work for a young person vary, but they tend to return to a small number of questions: what the person can and cannot do at present, what has changed, what the likely course is, and what would help. An expert answers these from the clinical assessment, the records and the person’s own account, weighed against each other.
It is useful to be explicit about the sources. The expert will want to know what the person reported, what family or education staff described, what the medical and therapy records show, and what the expert observed in the assessment. Each source has a different weight, and the report should say which is which.
Writing about education and work history
Many young people’s work histories are short, interrupted or never started. Education may have been disrupted by illness, bereavement, a move, or a long period of absence from school. A report should describe these events accurately, without suggesting that a gap in employment is itself a sign of a condition. Many young people who have never worked are doing exactly what their circumstances allow.
When the report refers to school attendance, qualifications or an apprenticeship that did not go ahead, it should say where the information came from. School records, a reference, or the person’s own account each carry a different level of confidence. Where the information is uncertain, say so.
Avoid moral language. Phrases such as “lazy”, “unwilling” or “choosing not to work” are not clinical findings, and they tend to weaken a report rather than strengthen it. Describe what the person does, what they report, and what the assessment shows, and leave the reader to draw the conclusion.
Preparing the instruction
Solicitors and families can help the expert by sending the material that bears directly on the question. For a young person, that is usually:
- A chronology of education, training and any work attempted, with dates.
- Relevant school or college records, including attendance and any support plans.
- Medical, therapy and Child and Adolescent Mental Health Services records where they exist.
- Any previous reports, with the date and the question each one answered.
- A short statement of the issues in dispute, so the expert knows what the instruction is for.
A clear chronology is worth more than a large bundle with no explanation. It helps the expert see when things changed, and it reduces the chance that an important detail is missed.
Keeping the report within the evidence
Use the language of evidence: the person “reported”, the records “show”, the observation was “consistent with” a view, and the expert’s opinion rests on specific reasons. Say what the evidence can answer and what it cannot. If the person’s prognosis is uncertain, say that, and say what would change it.
Do not use the national figures to support a particular opinion about the individual. If the review is relevant to the case, for example because the person’s education was interrupted in the way the review describes, the report can mention the context in one or two sentences. The conclusion should still come from the individual evidence.
Key points
- The review by Alan Milburn describes around one million 16 to 24 year olds who are NEET, and calls for a complete system reset.
- Its figures, including the government’s view that about a third of persistently absent Years 10 and 11 pupils in England become NEET, describe groups rather than individuals.
- A national statistic is background context, not evidence about a particular young person’s capacity for work.
- Base the opinion on the individual’s history, records, reports and the expert’s own assessment, and say where each source came from.
- Describe education and work gaps accurately, without implying a condition or passing moral judgement.
- A clear chronology from the instructing side helps the expert focus on what matters.
For more on the way an expert approaches other kinds of evidence, read our guide to online games and play-time evidence , or see the find an expert section if you are looking for a report writer.